Ally Kelley

Ally Kelley

Global Real Estate Advisor

Just like many others here in the Florida Keys, Ally is also a transplant – she was born and raised in St. Petersburg, FL then graduated from the University of South Florida. After college, she decided to completely change paths – she earned her real estate license then moved to the fabulous Florida Keys.

In such a heavily saturated vacation rental industry, Ally dove head first into the vacation rental market. By becoming a Licensed Property Manager, she oversaw the marketing, customer service, client relations, and licensing of 60 vacation rental homes while ensuring all guests and owners total satisfaction 24/7. This background became crucial in her future sales of clients’ investment properties.

During her first full year in residential real estate sales in 2017, she was named “Top Female Producer” by her company and “Rookie of the Year” by the local Marathon and Lower Keys Board of Realtors. Since then, she’s achieved “Top Female Producer” in 2019 and 2020. Recently in 2021, she was voted as the “Best Realtor in Marathon” in the Keys Weekly’s “Best of Marathon”. She’s also earned the National Association of Realtors designation of AHWD (At Home With Diversity), which allows her to better interact with global clients.

In such a competitive market, it is crucial to be aware of all new and upcoming issues that affect the local community and real estate industry. Ally has enjoyed serving on the Board of Directors for the Marathon and Lower Keys Board of Realtors since 2017 as past Director, Treasurer of the Board (2019, 2020), President-Elect (2021), and President for 2022. She’s also an active member of the Greater Marathon Chamber of Commerce, Rotary Club of Marathon, Business and Professional Women (BPW), and Leadership Monroe County Class XXVIII. To better serve the community’s health minded efforts, she also serves as a Board of Directors for the Fisherman’s Community Hospital Foundation Board as part of Baptist Health South Florida network. 

Purchasing or selling property in the Keys is a process where top notch resources are necessary to aid in successful transactions. As the “Best Realtor in Marathon”, Board of Director, and “Top Producer”, rest assured that Ally will guide you through the conscientious decisions during all steps of the buying or selling process while sharing her knowledge and passion for Florida Keys real estate and island lifestyle.


Meet Ally Kelley | A Personal Introduction Video 

Contact Us

Featured Listings


2919 Sombrero Boulevard

Debuting Marathon's Mermaid Manor to the market, coveted waterfront Sombrero Golf Course location with 125 ft of new concrete seawall, 15,000 lb boat lift, dinghy davit, and two 50-amp shore power ...

109 Anglers Drive, Unit 201, Marathon FL

Unbelievable price for an exquisite Sombrero Beach location. This 2nd story, 1,037 sq. ft. unit in Twin Anchors Condominium provides an updated kitchen with granite countertops, stainless steel app...

250 92nd Street, Marathon FL

Perfect starter or investment property located in Marathon, the heart of the Florida Keys. Quiet and private location with only 6 residential properties present on the entire street. Concrete groun...

Sold Listings


29550 W Cahill Court, Big Pine Key FL

Introducing ''Contemporary Keys Haven'', the epitome of a secure Florida Keys estate for divers, boaters, and sunset-lovers positioned behind a custom gated entry. This breathtaking oceanfront comp...

111 Coco Plum Drive, Marathon FL

Rare turn-key beachfront property with a 100 ft pier dock offers traditional coastal architecture with unobstructed open water views for a one of a kind, impeccable Keys estate. The private drive l...

11240 3rd Avenue Gulf

Casually and coastally elegant, this Gulfside garden cottage is perfectly nestled on an 8,485 sf lot with three bedrooms, three bathrooms, 1,656 sf living area, one-car garage, and 77 ft concrete s...

201 Sombrero Boulevard, Marathon FL

Owned by two of Marathon's Pioneers, spacious property located on protected Boot Key Harbor and Sombrero Golf Course: BEST of both worlds. Enjoy beautiful open water views and deepwater dockage. Ea...

121 Mockingbird Lane, Marathon FL

Exclusive Sombrero Beach location in Marathon with approximately 100 ft of deep dockage for large vessels on an expansive 16,450 square foot lot. Priced under appraised value, this solid concrete 3...

12399 Overseas Highway, Unit 10, Marathon FL

Income producing luxury end-unit and deeded 40 ft boat slip conveniently located in Marathon at picturesque Coral Lagoon Resort and Marina. This destination resort oasis allows nightly rentals and ...

Work With Us

Whether you are buying or selling your home, you can trust Ocean Sotheby's International Realty to provide a superior level of professional real estate services that exceed your expectations.

Contact Us